5am Saint label colour dilema

help us choose

5am Saint label colour dilema

We have writer's block, or whatever the beer label design equivalent is. We are trying to decide the packaging for our new 5% ale - 5am Saint. 5am Saint is a amber-red ale with low bitterness and insane hopiness.  So far we have only released a few bottles and casks of the prototype and people seem to dig it.

We now have to decide what colour to make the label. We have to find something which looks good by itself but also looks good as part of our core range for 2010 of Punk, 77, Trashy and 5am Saint.

We want your help in choosing the colour. Any other suggestions appreciated too.

Bad Black

black_400

Raconteur Red

red_400

Audacious Aquatic Mint

aqua_400

Your thoughts on the first draft of the label text would also be appreciated.

text_561

 

Share This

Join the Discussion

Comments (34)

Stuart Reekie 15.09.2009 @ 9:20pm
I would go with green- youve enough other Red and Black labels, green will - I hope! - stand out more in the line-up/on the shelf/in my fridge...
Alan Robertson 08.09.2009 @ 9:37pm
Red is good. Do not like the black at all really. And I would be careful with the rude words also as otherwise this will end up as another beer which requires modification before some sellers will touch it. Let your beer do tha talking and not anything else, lads.
Reluctant Scooper 04.09.2009 @ 7:49am
Go with the mint, tone down the text. Its a path youve already trod well in lighter shoes, this text is clod-hopping by comparison
Andrew DUnn 04.09.2009 @ 4:14am
The Red colour for sure - great colour descriptor for beer and really works in the line up as a team. Of course the obvious link to the colour of the beer is nice too!
colin mallon 03.09.2009 @ 11:27pm
James. I have a problem with your label: AND WE ARE THE FUCKING DOCTOR.... you just cant say that!!! I mean, unless of course you have a Phd or are an undercover medic. I am just concerned that you might even get put on the naughty step by an alcohol regulatory body....

Cheers

Colin, BrewDog Pusher, NZ

p.s Audacious Aquatic Mint
Bex Smith 03.09.2009 @ 8:07pm
mint defo it sticks out while complimenting the others
Jo 03.09.2009 @ 6:24pm
Green looks like Mouthwash
Black looks like Tokyo*
Red looks ACE.

Simples.
Mark, Real-Ale-Reviews.com 03.09.2009 @ 2:01pm
The red suits the beer name, but I think the mint complements the other colours in the range best and perhaps

Hmm, this is harder than picking the colours for fantasy football team!
Paul Raisey 03.09.2009 @ 2:00pm
New beer deserves a new fresh colour; it’s got to be ‘Audacious Aquatic Mint’ for me!
Maf 03.09.2009 @ 11:43am
Got it. How about a grey-blue on white?

http://img35.imageshack.us/img35/808/5smsaint.jpg
James Taylor 03.09.2009 @ 10:13am
I like the Green one, makes a good addition to the bright selection of labels you already use!
G Dunbar 02.09.2009 @ 10:37pm
Also – if you go with the green you may want to consider making the “5 AM” font slightly bigger as it’s somewhat drowned out by the light tone of the background.
G Dunbar 02.09.2009 @ 10:18pm
Ok...so on reflection – the best thing for me about the BrewDog label design is the “blank canvas” that is the 2 colour text and background. This lends itself (cost permitting) to be exploited e.g. the red dot in the first “o” of Tokyo. I’d love to see a BrewDog label split vertically/horizontally so you have a kind of negative text/background thing going on with the house font...
Rory 02.09.2009 @ 9:50pm
I would say the red. It looks good on its own and with the others.
Vittorio, therinkery.blogspot.com 02.09.2009 @ 8:25pm
I`m conflicted. On their own I think green is the weakest, but with the other bottles I think the green looks best. Fits in with the colour schema better. Maybe a less saturated red?
Taco 02.09.2009 @ 7:16pm
Crimson - should be a bleary 5AM blood shot eyes type of colour...
G Dunbar 02.09.2009 @ 6:38pm
ChickB – It’s all in the game...
G Dunbar 02.09.2009 @ 6:10pm
Love the green – but the red probably best suits the beer. The black might confuse some unsuspecting consumer into buying Tokyo* I can see the headlines now...
David M 02.09.2009 @ 5:39pm
If it is 5am saint, wouldnt a sunrise colour (gold fading to orange - or amber to red) be more appropriate?
And how about a halo?
craig garvie 02.09.2009 @ 4:59pm
I want to say Green as i like the Green best but i think the Red Suits this beer best.

But do keep the Green label for when you do a Mint version of the Tokyo
ChickB 02.09.2009 @ 4:41pm
Red is good, but the blurb is too close to Punk IPA (which is a straight lift from Arrogant Bastard Ale).

There are only so many ways you can say mainstream beer is piss without it starting to sound a bit trite.

I would go for something along the lines of the fact you have got as far as reading this means you are starting to get the message.

Obviously, you will probably want to throw a grandiloquent or two in there.

And you will probably want to keep the word fucking in there too, because the Portman Group have not been thrown a bone for a while....
Heather Brennan 02.09.2009 @ 4:05pm
I would say the red one because it seems more devil-ish. I also think a yellow and black label would work too. I would stay clear of green altogether because green makes you think of sick. Unless it was an organic beer and environmentally friendly made label I do not think green gives the right message.
Grant 02.09.2009 @ 3:50pm
Try make it a very dark green
Marco 02.09.2009 @ 3:37pm
Mint Great!!
Micke 02.09.2009 @ 3:27pm
I like the mint. Red is okay too. Label text is awesome
andy mogg 02.09.2009 @ 3:12pm
the red is good as is the mit but i think orange and black or black and orange would look awesome
David 02.09.2009 @ 2:29pm
Agree with Mint. for already stated reasons. text is a bit too condescending but nice use of the F word.
Maf 02.09.2009 @ 1:53pm
Now, most people will go for red and not dig the mint one - but you created it for a reason, yes? I would suggest that 5AM Saint is going to be closer to Trashy and Punk rather than a dangerous style ale (Dogma, Hardcore, etc - the ones with black labels essentially). Because of this, the mint would go well as its a similar saturation to the purple and cyan of the afore-mentioned ales. You look at it - its white writing on a one of the lighter backgrounds, you know its going to be one of the more easy going brews you do. Then again, youll probably just go red and then cry when you try and find a colour for mass-market Rake.
Dave P 02.09.2009 @ 1:28pm
go with the red, itll catch the eye when on display and maybe people will ask what it is and maybe buy a bottle rather than going for corona or peroni all the time

eejits
UnfriendlyGhost 02.09.2009 @ 12:59pm
Do not like the black at all, too close to the 77. Red feels more medical and it is a red ale, so I would go with that - but definitely use the mint on a different beer, it is a great colour. I think the label text is a bit too hectoring - personally I would go with just the last three paras, from At Brewdog onwards, in bigger type!
Ian 02.09.2009 @ 12:13pm
I would say the red, too -- when the bottles are lying on their side in the fridge it would be easier to see which one is the 77 and which the 5am, thereby saving me at least five seconds of precious time that I could be using for drinking.

And that label. Oh my. Yes.
Jason Cale 02.09.2009 @ 11:45am
Red stands its ground with the other bottles, and I think suits the name, and indeed the label.

Cant wait to try it.
The Beer Nut 02.09.2009 @ 11:39am
I like the mint one, to fit the medical theme.

And then wait for the accusations of health-claims...
Ryan Lower 02.09.2009 @ 11:20am
Red - I find it more medicinal than the other colours - matches the blurb

R.